For nearly a decade, the Wellnitz family murders haunted the small town of Columbia, Kentucky. The tight knit community had no clue why these good people were mercilessly executed in their own home. They were known for their thriving veterinary clinic and their kind hearts. But someone had been viciously murdered the family and even though investigators were pretty sure they knew who did it, the case went cold. It took ten years and heroic undercover work to get justice for the Wellnitz family.
photo Gallery
Show Notes
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional writing by Erica Kelley
Edited and Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Suggested by Dana Schmidt
SOURCES:
1. Meg Wellnitz, Bill Meece Convicted Of Killing Wellnitz Family | Crime News (oxygen.com)
2. An Unexpected Killer 2022 | A Family Affair | An Unexpected Killer S03E15 (youtube.com)
3. Meece v. Commonwealth, 348 S.W.3d 627 – CourtListener.com
4. Commonwealth v. Grise, 558 S.W.3d 923 – CourtListener.com
5. Kentucky Offender Search - Kentucky Department of Corrections - Offender Online Lookup System
7. Margaret Wellnitz Obituary (2014) - Lexington, KY - Lexington Herald-Leader (legacy.com)
8. Elizabeth A “Beth” Preston Wellnitz (1952-1993) - Find a Grave Memorial
9. Dr Joseph Verl “Joe” Wellnitz (1942-1993) - Find a Grave Memorial
10. Mrs Margaret Anne “Meg” Wellnitz Appleton (1974-2014) - Find a Grave Memorial
11. Dennis Verl Wellnitz (1972-1993) - Find a Grave Memorial
12. Leonard Lee Preston Sr. (1922-1987) - Find a Grave Memorial
13. Mary Powers Preston (1920-2020) - Find a Grave Memorial
14. 1LT Leonard Lee Preston Jr. (1944-1969) - Find a Grave Memorial
15. William Powers Preston (1949-1985) - Find a Grave Memorial
16. Aug 08, 1965, page 171 - The Courier-Journal at Newspapers.com
17. Dec 12, 1971, page 37 - The Jackson Sun at Newspapers.com
18. Feb 08, 1976, page 113 - The Courier-Journal at Newspapers.com
19. Dec 05, 1978, page 26 - The Lexington Herald at Newspapers.com
20. Mar 12, 1974, page 19 - The Lexington Herald at Newspapers.com
21. Feb 27, 1993, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
22. Feb 27, 1993, page 12 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
23. Feb 28, 1993, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
24. Feb 28, 1993, page 10 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
25. Mar 01, 1993, page 12 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
26. Mar 14, 1993, page 22 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
27. Jun 07, 1993, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
28. Jun 07, 1993, page 5 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
29. Nov 12, 1993, page 21 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
30. Feb 26, 1994, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
31. Feb 26, 1994, page 6 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
32. May 22, 1994, page 15 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
33. May 22, 1994, page 22 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
34. May 24, 1994, page 11 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
35. Mar 22, 1995, page 59 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
36. Mar 01, 2003, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
37. Mar 01, 2003, page 9 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
38. Mar 08, 2003, page 13 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
39. Mar 08, 2003, page 14 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
40. Mar 12, 2003, page 15 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
41. May 01, 2003, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
42. May 01, 2003, page 10 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
43. Jun 03, 2003, page 13 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
44. Jun 04, 2003, page 19 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
45. Nov 15, 2004, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
46. Nov 15, 2004, page 9 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
47. Nov 16, 2004, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
48. Nov 16, 2004, page 8 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
49. Dec 29, 2004, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
50. Dec 29, 2004, page 8 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
51. Jan 05, 2005, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
52. Jan 05, 2005, page 4 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
53. Jan 26, 2005, page 27 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
54. Feb 03, 2005, page 12 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
55. Jun 01, 2005, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
56. Jun 01, 2005, page 7 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
57. May 10, 2006, page 16 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
58. Jul 13, 2006, page 23 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
59. Aug 20, 2006, page 17 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
60. Aug 20, 2006, page 18 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
61. Aug 31, 2006, page 29 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
62. Aug 31, 2006, page 34 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
63. Sep 14, 2006, page 23 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
64. Sep 14, 2006, page 24 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
65. Sep 15, 2006, page 27 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
66. Sep 16, 2006, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
67. Sep 16, 2006, page 6 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
68. Sep 19, 2006, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
69. Sep 19, 2006, page 6 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
70. Oct 21, 2006, page 1 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
71. Oct 21, 2006, page 14 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
72. Feb 29, 2008, page 21 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
73. Feb 29, 2008, page 22 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
74. Mar 12, 2008, page 35 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
75. Jun 17, 2011, page A3 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
76. Jun 17, 2011, page A6 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
77. Jun 14, 2013, page A3 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
78. Jun 14, 2013, page A4 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
79. Aug 14, 2020, page A5 - Lexington Herald-Leader at Newspapers.com
80. Ancestry.com